Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't understand this recurrent point: computer power is "wasted" almost everywhere. At least Bitcoin use this power to build a decentralized currency.


> computer power is "wasted" almost everywhere. At least Bitcoin use this power to build a decentralized currency.

Pinning a GPU or ASIC at 100% undeniably draws more power than an everyday user idling around Facebook on their Macbook Air (~21W MAXED, so likely 7W)

Whether it's worth it is the question.

A back-of-the-envelope calculation gives me $12Mn USD per day as the approximate global cost of electricity given the current global hashrate of 375Mn GH/s, for 0.05¢/kWh, assuming everyone is using reasonably modern, efficient (?) ASICs like a Spondoolies SP35 Yukon at 5.5TH/s for 3850W.

If that's for a $300Mn USD daily market, that's not particularly efficient. Nor particularly inefficient either, admittedly. Democratic, for sure ;)

EDIT: initially forgot to include some time units, thanks jsprogrammer!


> A back-of-the-envelope calculation gives me $12Mn USD per day

3600.00 BTC or $1m is paid as subsidy per day.

Are you saying that people are spending 12x that on power?

I dont think so.


Do your own calculation and see what you find, instead of think. This is HN after all. :)

You have all the relevant numbers in my post after all: maybe I made a mistake? That certainly possible :P, since you seem to be right about the rewards paid per day.

Or maybe people willingly factor in power costs as a price of speculating on a volatile, trending currency? Or maybe most power costs are actually carried in low-cost areas rather than North America and Europe, so my $0.05/kWh is an overestimate?


>$12Mn USD

per what?

This number is pretty meaningless without knowing what timeframe that amount of costs are incurred.


Oops, good save. Thanks!

It's per day. (I think. :P)

Today's average hashrate is ~397Mn GH/s, and I used 375 instead, to be conservative/fair.

https://blockchain.info/charts/hash-rate


The spot price of BTC has been steadily rising. Someone must be getting more than $12,000,000 USD / day in value out of it.


It's wasted relative to other methods (e.g. proof of stake, Stellar) that many people believe can provide close enough to the same properties.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: